Skip to main content

SHY vs VGSH: ETF Comparison

iShares 1-3 Year Treasury Bond ETF compared with Vanguard Short-Term Treasury ETF: costs, income, size, performance and the top holdings they share.

SHY vs VGSH at a Glance

SHY (iShares 1-3 Year Treasury Bond ETF) is run by BlackRock and launched in July 2002; VGSH (Vanguard Short-Term Treasury ETF) is run by Vanguard and launched in November 2009. As of Nov 20, 2026, VGSH is cheaper: its 0.03% expense ratio costs about $3 a year per $10,000 invested, versus $15 for SHY (0.15%). SHY manages $26.18B in assets across 92 holdings, VGSH $34.98B in assets across 94 holdings.

As of Nov 20, 2026, SHY has a trailing dividend yield of 3.61% and VGSH 3.78%. Over the past year SHY's price changed −1.99% versus −2.00% for VGSH; over five years the figures are −5.12% and −5.66% (price change, dividends excluded).

Among the top 25 holdings of SHY and the top 26 of VGSH (holdings as of Oct 4, 2026), 14 positions are shared. They make up 21.55% of SHY and 19.00% of VGSH; the largest common ones are T.3.5 01.31.28, T.4.625 04.30.29 and T.4.25 06.30.29.

Key Figures Side by Side

SHY and VGSH key figures side by side
MetricSHYVGSH
Expense ratio0.15%0.03%
Annual cost per $10,000$15$3
Dividend yield (TTM)3.61%3.78%
Assets under management$26.18B$34.98B
Holdings9294
1-year price change−1.99%−2.00%
5-year price change−5.12%−5.66%
Asset classFixed IncomeFixed Income
IssuerBlackRockVanguard
InceptionJul 21, 2002Nov 18, 2009

Source: Exchange price data and fund disclosures. Data as of Nov 20, 2026. Data sources and methodology

Shared Top Holdings

14 of the top 25 SHY and top 26 VGSH positions overlap, by weight in each fund

Holdings that appear in the top positions of both SHY and VGSH
HoldingSHY weightVGSH weight
T.3.5 01.31.281.73%2.05%
T.4.625 04.30.291.54%1.43%
T.4.25 06.30.291.49%1.35%
T.4.5 05.31.291.50%1.34%
T.3.625 08.31.291.82%1.33%
T.1.125 02.29.281.36%1.32%
T.2.875 05.15.281.37%1.31%
T.4 07.31.291.31%1.39%
T.4.25 01.15.281.36%1.29%
T.1.25 04.30.281.99%1.26%
T.3.75 05.15.281.30%1.24%
T.3.875 03.31.282.11%1.23%
T.4.125 03.31.291.35%1.23%
T.1.25 05.31.281.32%1.23%

Source: Fund holdings disclosures (largest positions only). Data as of Oct 4, 2026. Data sources and methodology

Interactive SHY vs VGSH Comparison

Performance Comparison

No chart data available

Comparison Results

Marked values are the best in their row where higher or lower is clearly better.

Side-by-side comparison; best value per row is marked
ETF
SHY logo
SHY
VGSH logo
VGSH
Price$81.61$57.86
AUM$26.18B$34.98B
Expense Ratio0.15%0.03% (best)
Holdings9294
Dividend Yield3.61%3.78% (best)
Asset ClassFixed IncomeFixed Income

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, SHY or VGSH?

VGSH is cheaper as of Nov 20, 2026: its expense ratio is 0.03% versus 0.15% for SHY. On a $10,000 investment that is about $3 a year against $15, a difference of roughly $12 a year.

Which pays a higher dividend, SHY or VGSH?

VGSH pays more as of Nov 20, 2026: its trailing twelve-month dividend yield is 3.78% versus 3.61% for SHY.

Do SHY and VGSH hold the same securities?

Among the top 25 holdings of SHY and the top 26 of VGSH (holdings as of Oct 4, 2026), 14 positions are shared. They make up 21.55% of SHY and 19.00% of VGSH; the largest common ones are T.3.5 01.31.28, T.4.625 04.30.29 and T.4.25 06.30.29.

Which has performed better, SHY or VGSH?

SHY has done better over the past year to Nov 20, 2026: its price changed −1.99% against −2.00% for VGSH. Over five years SHY changed −5.12% and VGSH −5.66%. These are price changes and exclude dividends.

More Comparisons