Shiller CAPE Ratio
What is Shiller CAPE Ratio?
The cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratio: the price of a stock index divided by the average of ten years of inflation-adjusted earnings. It smooths the business cycle to gauge market-wide valuation.
Last reviewed by the FinSpry Team on
Overview
The Shiller CAPE ratio, short for cyclically adjusted price to earnings, divides the level of a stock index by the average of its earnings over the previous ten years, with every year adjusted for inflation. It is most often quoted for the S&P 500.
Yale economist Robert Shiller and John Campbell published the measure in 1988, and Shiller made it widely known in his 2000 book Irrational Exuberance. The idea goes back to Benjamin Graham and David Dodd, who suggested valuing stocks on several years of average earnings. A one-year P/E ratio swings with the business cycle: profits collapse in recessions, which pushes the P/E up just when stocks are cheap, and they peak in booms, which makes stocks look cheap when they are not. Averaging ten years of real earnings smooths those swings out.
Alternative Names: CAPE Ratio, Cyclically Adjusted P/E, Shiller P/E, PE10, P/E 10
Formula
CAPE = Real Index Price ÷ 10-Year Average of Real Earnings
Real Earnings for a Past Year = Nominal Earnings × (Current CPI ÷ CPI in That Year)
Where:
- Real Index Price
- The current level of the index, for example the S&P 500, expressed in today's dollars
- Real Earnings
- The index's per-share earnings for each of the last ten years, restated in today's dollars using the Consumer Price Index so that old and new profits are comparable. See inflation rate
- 10-Year Average
- The simple average of those ten real earnings figures, which covers at least one full business cycle in most periods
FinSpry does not calculate the CAPE ratio. It is a market-level measure built from long index and inflation histories, and Shiller publishes the monthly series for the S&P 500 on his Yale website. For individual stocks, FinSpry shows trailing and forward P/E on each statistics page, and the Buffett indicator page covers another market-wide valuation gauge.
Calculation Example
The figures below are hypothetical and chosen to show the method, not the current market:
Example Index - Data:
| Current Index Level | 5,000 |
|---|---|
| Real Earnings, Years 1-5 (Oldest First) | $110, $118, $125, $130, $138 |
| Real Earnings, Years 6-10 | $145, $160, $170, $195, $209 |
Step 1: Adjust Each Year for Inflation
For example, $100 of earnings ten years ago with CPI at 240 then and 310 now: $100 × (310 ÷ 240) = $129.17 in today's dollars. The table above already shows real figures.
Step 2: Average the Ten Years
$110 + $118 + $125 + $130 + $138 + $145 + $160 + $170 + $195 + $209 = $1,500
$1,500 ÷ 10 = $150
Step 3: CAPE Ratio
5,000 ÷ $150
= 33.3
Interpretation: On the latest year's earnings alone, the index trades at 5,000 ÷ $209 = 23.9 times earnings. The CAPE of 33.3 is higher because earnings grew strongly over the decade, so the ten-year average sits well below the latest year. The CAPE assumes profits will drift back toward their long-run trend rather than stay at the most recent level.
How to Interpret
Over the full US record that Shiller reconstructed back to the 1880s, the S&P 500 CAPE has averaged in the mid to high teens. It rose above 40 at the end of 1999, just before the dot-com crash, and fell below 10 in the early 1980s. Research by Shiller and others found that a higher starting CAPE has gone along with lower average returns over the following ten years, but the link is loose and says almost nothing about the next twelve months.
Reading the Level:
Below the Long-Run Average
Prices are low relative to a decade of real profits. Historically, ten-year returns that started from such levels have been above average, though these periods often come during recessions or high inflation, when buying feels hardest.
Moderately Above the Average
Readings in the 20s have been common since the 1990s. Lower interest rates, higher profit margins and a larger weight of technology companies may justify part of the premium over the early twentieth century.
Far Above the Average
Readings above 30 have occurred before some of the largest market declines, including 1929 and 2000. A high CAPE signals that expected long-term returns are lower, not that a crash is due on any particular date. The market can stay at high levels for years.
Why It Matters
- Long-Term Return Expectations: Inverting the CAPE gives a cyclically adjusted earnings yield. A CAPE of 25 implies a 4% yield (1 ÷ 25), which investors often compare with real bond yields.
- Less Distorted by Recessions: In 2009 the S&P 500's one-year P/E jumped above 100 because profits collapsed, even though prices had fallen sharply. The ten-year average did not swing that way.
- Known Weaknesses: Changes in accounting rules, such as stricter write-downs of goodwill, lower reported earnings in some years and raise the CAPE. Share buybacks in place of dividends also make per-share earnings grow faster than they used to, which the old averages do not reflect.
Related Financial Ratios
These related metrics provide additional insights for financial analysis:
Price to Earnings Ratio (P/E)
The one-year version, based on the last twelve months of reported earnings.
Buffett Indicator
Total US stock market value divided by GDP, another gauge of market-wide valuation.
Earnings Yield
Earnings divided by price. The inverse of CAPE gives a cyclically adjusted version.
Inflation Rate
The CPI change used to restate past earnings in today's dollars.
More in Valuation Ratios & Multiples
Is the stock cheap or expensive?
- Price to earnings ratio (P/E)
- Price to book ratio (P/B)
- Price to sales ratio (P/S)
- PEG ratio
- EV/EBIT ratio
- EV/EBITDA ratio
- EV/sales ratio
- Enterprise value
- Market capitalization
- Buffett Indicator
- Earnings yield
- Free cash flow yield
- Price to free cash flow ratio (P/FCF)
- Graham number
- Peter Lynch fair value
- Forward P/E Ratio