Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

SIGINASDAQFinancialsInsurance - Property & Casualty

$98.79- (-)1Y +19.83%

As of Oct 26, 2026 close

Market cap: $5.92B
P/E (TTM): 11.89
Forward P/E: 8.51
Dividend yield: 1.87%
52-week range: $72.78$100.40
Volume (live): -
Avg. volume (3M): 585.42K

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) Analyst Forecast

Analyst consensus ratings, 12-month price targets, and expert recommendations for Selective Insurance Group, Inc. stock.

Analyst Consensus Rating

Investment consensus from 8 professional research analysts

Consensus Rating

Hold

Based on 8 unique analysts

(12 total ratings in last 90 days)

Medium Confidence3.0:1 Buy/Sell

Average Price Target

$101.43

+2.94% upside

Loading chart...

Strong Sell

Sell

Hold

Buy

Strong Buy

Latest SIGI Analyst Ratings & Recommendations

Recent analyst recommendations with rating changes and price target updates (last 90 days)

Date	Analyst	Firm	Action	Rating	Price Target
Oct 23, 2026	Paul Newsome	Piper Sandler	Maintains	Hold	$97.00
Oct 21, 2026	Zacks Equity Research	Zacks Equity Research	Initiates Coverage	Hold	-
Oct 20, 2026	Michael Zaremski	BMO Capital	Maintains	Hold	$97.00 → $98.00 +1.00 (+1.0%)
Oct 13, 2026	Michael Phillips CFA	Oppenheimer	Maintains	Buy	$115.00
Oct 12, 2026	Meyer Shields	KBW	Maintains	Hold	$102.00 → $90.00 −12.00 (−11.8%)
Oct 12, 2026	Rowland Mayor	RBC Capital	Maintains	Buy	$115.00
Oct 6, 2026	Bob Huang	Morgan Stanley	Reiterates	Sell	$80.00
Sep 28, 2026	Paul Newsome	Piper Sandler	Maintains	Hold	$105.00 → $97.00 −8.00 (−7.6%)
Sep 25, 2026	Zacks Equity Research	Zacks Equity Research	Initiates Coverage	Hold	-
Sep 21, 2026	Rowland Mayor	RBC Capital	Maintains	Buy	$115.00
Aug 14, 2026	Unknown Analyst	Oppenheimer	Reiterates	Buy	$105.00 → $115.00 +10.00 (+9.5%)
Jul 30, 2026	Meyer Shields	KBW	Maintains	Hold	$101.00 → $102.00 +1.00 (+1.0%)

Paul Newsome

Piper Sandler

HoldMaintains

$97.00

Oct 23

Zacks Equity Research

HoldInitiates Coverage

Oct 21

Michael Zaremski

BMO Capital

HoldMaintains

$97.00 → $98.00

Oct 20

Michael Phillips CFA

Oppenheimer

BuyMaintains

$115.00

Oct 13

Meyer Shields

KBW

HoldMaintains

$102.00 → $90.00

Oct 12

Rowland Mayor

RBC Capital

BuyMaintains

$115.00

Oct 12

Bob Huang

Morgan Stanley

SellReiterates

$80.00

Oct 6

Paul Newsome

Piper Sandler

HoldMaintains

$105.00 → $97.00

Sep 28

Zacks Equity Research

HoldInitiates Coverage

Sep 25

Rowland Mayor

RBC Capital

BuyMaintains

$115.00

Sep 21

Unknown Analyst

Oppenheimer

BuyReiterates

$105.00 → $115.00

Aug 14

Meyer Shields

KBW

HoldMaintains

$101.00 → $102.00

Jul 30

Source: Professional analyst ratings and price targets from the last 90 days. Data as of Oct 23, 2026. Data sources and methodology

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the analyst consensus rating for SIGI?

The analyst consensus rating for SIGI is Hold, based on the latest ratings from 8 analysts over the last 90 days.

What is the average price target for SIGI?

The average 12-month price target for SIGI is $101.43, representing an upside of 2.9% from the Oct 27, 2026 close of $98.53.

What do analyst ratings mean?

Analyst ratings indicate investment recommendations: Strong Buy and Buy are bullish signals suggesting the stock may outperform. Hold means the stock is fairly valued. Sell and Strong Sell are bearish signals suggesting potential underperformance. These ratings are based on fundamental analysis and valuation models.

What is a price target?

A price target is an analyst's projection of a stock's fair value over a specific timeframe, typically 12 months. Analysts use fundamental analysis, financial modeling, and industry comparisons to estimate where the stock should trade. Price targets can range from low (conservative) to high (optimistic) estimates.